A Different Man Review – A Chilling and Unique Thriller
Directed by Aaron Schimberg, this film stars Adam Pearson, Renate Reinsve, and Sebastian Stan. Schimberg’s earlier work, Chained For Life, hinted at great potential, and A Different Man continues to explore intriguing themes.
Sebastian Stan shines as Edward, a man whose life has been shaped by neurofibromatosis, a condition that causes benign tumors to form on his face. This leads to societal rejection, leaving Edward to navigate life in a one-bedroom apartment marked by a foreboding stain on the ceiling. His aspirations to perform are consistently thwarted by the reactions of those around him. When a new neighbor, Ingrid, played by Renate Reinsve, enters the picture, Edward finds himself smitten but doubtful of any chance of romance due to his appearance.
A pivotal moment arrives when Edward’s doctor introduces him to an experimental drug trial that holds the promise of transforming his life. As he embarks on this journey, his appearance begins to shift dramatically – with grotesque slivers of skin peeling away to reveal a new, conventionally attractive face. This transformation brings excitement, yet it also stirs feelings of dread. Despite his newfound looks and a successful career as a realtor, Edward grapples with deep-seated insecurities, especially when encountering Oswald, portrayed by Adam Pearson, who shares the same daunting condition yet exudes charm and confidence.
Schimberg’s A Different Man builds on the themes of identity and performance established in his debut. While this film boasts a larger budget, it maintains a quirky sense of humor alongside a dark undertone. The narrative subtly echoes the existential themes found in Dostoevsky’s The Double and pays homage to David Lynch’s The Elephant Man, though it offers less pathos than its predecessors. In an interesting cultural nod, one might even draw parallels to a classic Simpsons episode, “Pygmoelian,” where Moe Szyslak undergoes a drastic makeover that leads to unexpected success.
Though the film explores the age-old adage that looks do not dictate life’s ease, Schimberg breathes fresh energy into this concept, thanks in part to Pearson’s captivating performance, which beautifully contrasts with Stan’s anxious, restless Edward. The film also benefits from exceptional production design, enhancing its grim ambiance even in seemingly mundane settings.
While the narrative might lose some momentum in its latter parts, A Different Man successfully crafts an atmospheric and distinctive thriller. It thoughtfully interrogates society’s condescending views on difference and disability while delving into complex issues of authorship and the right to share others’ stories.
This commitment to elevating remarkable cinema and the artists behind it is at the core of our mission. By supporting independent journalism, you can help us continue to deliver unique insights, essays, and film recommendations. Published October 3, 2024.